HackerPapers

arXiv:0801.1734gr-qc

The Volume Inside a Black Hole

Brandon S. DiNunno, Richard A. Matzner

Early discovery. Linked by one identifiable commenter. This paper is outside the main ranking; a mention is not an endorsement.

Abstract

The horizon (the surface) of a black hole is a null surface, defined by those hypothetical "outgoing" light rays that just hover under the influence of the strong gravity at the surface. Because the light rays are orthogonal to the spatial 2-dimensional surface at one instant of time, the surface of the black hole is the same for all observers (i.e. the same for all coordinate definitions of "instant of time"). This value is 4*(pi)* (2Gm/c^2)^2 for nonspinning black holes, with G= Newton's constant, c= speed of light, and m= mass of the black hole. The 3-dimensional spatial volume inside a black hole, in contrast, depends explicitly on the definition of time, and can even be time dependent, or zero. We give examples of the volume found inside a standard, nonspinning spherical black hole, for several different standard time-coordinate definitions. Elucidating these results for the volume provides a new pedagogical resource of facts already known in principle to the relativity community, but rarely worked out.

arXiv comments
17 pages, 5 figures
Journal reference
Gen.Rel.Grav.42:63-76,2010
DOI
doi:10.1007/s10714-009-0814-x
Subjects
gr-qcGeneral Relativity and Quantum Cosmology

On Hacker News

Linked by 1 identifiable commenter in 3 comments across 3 threads, from Nov 2023 to May 2025.

Comments linking this paper, per year.

Discussed in comments3 threads

    • The mean density of the interior is much much much lower than you think, because the Schwarzschild interior volume is enormously larger than that of a closed Euclidean 3-ball of the Schwarzschild radius. Some details: Christodoulou & Rovelli 2014 showed that the maximal interior…

      raattgiftView on HNParent context

    • The area of the Sun and the Earth and every other self-gravitating body in hydrostatic equilibrium is also proportional to the body's mass. Volumes are weird though: unlike area, relativistic volume can depend on the body's (and the spacetime's) history and composition rather…

      raattgiftView on HNParent context

    • The interior volume of a black hole doesn't work much like the interior volume of 3-ball <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ball_(mathematics)>, except perhaps the regions closest to (but inside) the horizon in the limit of the largest black holes. The short version is that a black…

      raattgiftView on HNParent context

Submitted to Hacker News

Connected through shared HN threads, not inferred similarity or a recommendation.